Stargirl, the strange new girl, and Leo, become girlfriend and boyfriend. Leo is awed by how Stargirl can ignore the teasing of their classmates. Leo soon finds himself in love with Stargirl and, but they are finding that the whispering of their classmates is getting worse and worse. Leo wants Stargirl to be normal. One day Stargirl comes to school and she is dressed normally. She looks like a normal teenager. Leo is proud of her but Stargirl is no longer happy. Can Leo and Stargirl fix their relationship? Or will it crumble like Stargirl's popularity if she changes back? Stargirl loves Leo, but what if he can't love her back for who she is?